Troy movie historically accurate

Why doesnt hollywood make historically accurate movies. A hundred stories drift lazily between the pages, and over the water from gatsbys swimming pool to the green light on daisys dock. With the help of achilles, the greeks are able to fight the never before defeated trojans. The movie sidesteps the existence of the greek gods, turns its heroes into action movie cliches and demonstrates that were getting tired of computergenerated armies. It was the 8th highestgrossing film of 2004 and currently is in the top 250 highest. Helen says in the movie that she was sent to marry. Likewise, my recognition of what happened at gettysburg did not diminish my appreciation of ronald maxwells historically accurate retelling.

Also, i know that coins placed on the deceased were for crossing the river styx, but were they placed on the eyes, or under the tongue or either. Asfar as almost everything else about the film goes, however, it is historically accurate in a way that no other film showcasing this particular subject could ever hope to be. As generations continue to revolutionize, various new prospects lie ahead for the many inhabitants of earth, no matter what corner they live in. Smellin of troy what follows is a partial list of discrepancies between troy the bigbudget hollywood movie and troy the epic poem and archeological history. More than 600 years ago, king henry v led an army to victory on the field of.

The costumes are ripped straight from historical text and pictures. In the ancient greek world, there was always a lot of respect given to the king of the nation, whether he deserved it or not. Egyptian warfare and the largest chariot battle in history. Hes going to take the beach of troy with fifty men. For more on the movie troy look for the commentary assessing the evidence for the trojan wars, on the archaeological institute of americas website by c. It is based, loosely, on homers illiad, which in turn is only extremely loosely based on any historical fact. Historical accuracy of the movie troy the paper will be about the historical accuracy of the movie troy which tells the story of the trojan war. In baz luhrmanns new movie the great gatsby, the sixth. But, at a runtime of nearly three hours, troy is the most thorough. The battle of megiddo was the first reliably recorded battle, and not long after the battle of kadesh would claim the title of the largest chariot battle ever, despite chariot warfare persisting for nearly 1,000 more years.

They match the costumes, props, set design, and more. The trojans, thinking that the greeks had sailed away and left the horse as a. There are several inaccuracies in the 2004 film troy, directed by wolfgang peterson and starring brad pitt and eric bana. The trojan war was an epic siege carried out by the achaean greek kingdoms against the city of troy, around 1250 bc. Troy is the name of the bronze age city attacked in the trojan war, a popular story in the mythology of ancient greece, and the name given to the archaeological site in the northwest of asia minor now turkey which has revealed a large and prosperous city occupied over millennia. To counter this, hollywood directors and producers alike create fantastical films that bring to life. Looking at its historical accuracy, we can find the good and bad representations as well as the truly ugly decisions that truly twist history. What separates master and commander from a legion of similar movies are its production values. A good deal of the movie was historically accurate, and the principles behind the movie were also pretty much accurate, but a good deal of hollywood went into it as well. The historical accuracy of 8 classic movies by alexander meddings. Brian rose, one of the directors of the current excavations at the site and a professor at the university of cincinnati, and see the troia projekt site.

James holoka, professor foreign languages and history at eastern michigan university, who notes that despite this list he did enjoy the movie. Historically, troy was an anatolian city that had a number of greek customs and traditions, but was an enemy of the more greek city. The 2004 troy movie is not historically accurate for the following reasons. The new, eightpart netflix historical drama series, troy. What are historical inaccuracies of the movie troy. The 2004 epic film troy catches quite the break when it comes to historical films. The trojan war lasted for 10 years while in the movie it lasted in a few weeks. Troy is an adaptation of homers great epic, the film follows the assault on troy by the united greek forces and chronicles the fates of the men.

What is historically incorrect about the movie troy. Although the siege of troy is considered a myth, the city actually did exist in the 10th century b. There has been much scholarly debate as to whether mythical troy actually existed and if so whether the. As achilles ship nears the trojan shores, agamemnon snidely asks, whats the fool doing. Fall of a city, debuted this week on the streaming service, after running in the united kingdom on bbc one in february. The film was adapted by homers great epic poem, the iliad. Despite the awesomeness that is the 300 film and the sequel the epic battles, the amazing directing, the incredible cinematography by zack snyder, and all the impressive special effects our mission in this site is very specific, and thus, this article. Evidently, the film troy is historically accurate because it correctly portrays the respect given to women in the ancient greek class system.

Looking at its historical accuracy, we can find the good and bad. Both agamemnon and his brother menelaus survive the war in the iliad. The film troy is based around the ancient writer homers epic poem the iliad, written around the 8th century bc, in which the wellknown known heroes achilles, hector and paris wage war against each other for the sake of honour, land and the hand of helen. At best it is a mythic version of events that may or may not happened in real life. The show tells the story of the 10year siege of troy, set in the th century bc. When examined meticulously, it is clearly evident however, that the film troy, is historically accurate as it is based on true facts from the ancient greek life. Film analysis troy 2004 historical accuracy of troy. Another division of the military, one of the most important in fact, is the weapons. All we see is the clash between two largely faceless armies hacking at each other. Both historically and in the film, donovan was a new york attorney and former prosecutor at the nuremberg trials who was called upon to defend abel in american court. How the movie troy doesnt even come close to historys history.

The historical inaccuracies in 300 today i found out. Troy, starring brad pitt, is a historical travesty film the guardian. Wolfgang petersens 2004 film, troy, isnt historically accurate and it isnt faithful to its literary source. In homers the iliad, facts about the fall of troy and wars in the region are fictionalized to improve the quality of the story, and make it more. Todays post will be part 2 of the series on bridge of spies, focusing on the negotiations themselves and the treatment of the main character, james donovan. Despite the inaccuracies, there are also a number of ways in. At a time when technology is changing so rapidly, the histories, traditions and cultures of the past are sometimes forgotten, if not lost altogether. First off, historical accuracy is not a binary state that is either true or false. E and thus starts to prove that the film troy is historically accurate. Film analysis troy 2004 historical accuracy of troy uk essays.

The movie troy, from hollywood has been one of the greatest hollywood movie ever made, it was nominated for more than 10 awards and got into the best of. It is not an adaption of homers iliad or odyssey but rather an original take on the greek myths, and covers some ground only alluded to in those works. How historically accurate is the movie troy history wiki. Better a couple of hundred sweaty warriors than two masses of 50,000 men marching toward one another across a sea.

Elena gottesman, rachel lee, and taylor wilson the trojan horse historical accuracy during the war, the greeks moved their ships and hid inside of a hollow wooden horse. Confederate peace commissioners were trying to work out an end to the war, the house of. The 2004 epic film troy catches quite the break when it comes to historical. Each of those films also took liberties with the source material. Troy is based on the epic poem the iliad by homer, according to the credits. Yo nobody, the movie rocked and was pretty accurate due to the fact that trojan architecture was what it was in the movie, bronze was used for weapons, etc. What hurts troy is that theres no imagination or energy to the battles. Troy the film troy was directed by wolfgang peterson and produced in 2004. Here are 20 embarrassing movie costume mistakes that should have never made it onscreen. Once battle was initiated however, the men separated and fought individually. Troy made more than 73% of its revenues outside the united states. These are the films that actually got history right.

Detail from the procession of the trojan horse in troy by domenico. Coastal mexico is an endangered turtle habitat, so to be granted permission to set up the greek encampment and build boats on the large stretch of beach, the film crew implemented. The characters from the iliad were portrayed by many wellknown actors including, brad pitt, orlando bloom, and eric bana. As the movie shows, it was an intense time in washington. I think all the complaints about troy not being historically accurate are distracting from the real problem the film is the biggest pile of rubbish seen for a very long time. At least, thats the thought process behind the bbc and netflixs latest epic miniseries, troy. So to ask if any accountstorymovietv series concerning the trojan wa.

So they set off with 1,000 ships holding 50,000 greeks to troy. Achilles storyline is actually fairly accurate but many other deaths are not. Troy 2004, helen of troy 2003, troy fall of a city 2018, the trojan horse, and more. Many of them seem purposely carried out to appeal to audiences in the 21 st century. A labor of love for director attenborough, the preamble wording above is perhaps in some way his excuse if. The purpose of this essay is to answer the question of how accurate the hollywood movie, troy, really was and whether it portrayed homers tragic, charming side of the story or the predicted historical side. These films informed, inspired and moved its audience with its true to life dedication to its characters, setting and story. This event in the movie was clearly an accurate portrayal of fighting formations in greece during 1250 b. Troy, starring brad pitt, is a historical travesty film. The question isnt which of these is your favorite, but rather. The trojan war itself is, strictly speaking, not true history in the sense of the word. The battle of agincourt in 1415 was immortalized by shakespeare in henry v, and features in the king, as well. I thoroughly enjoyed the film but then, i went to be entertained not taught greek history. Due to the political situation in iraq, the location for scale shots was moved from morocco to mexico, an ideal alternate choice with its broad beach.

Fall of a city is a britishamerican miniseries based on the trojan war and the love affair between paris and helen. However, the rushed decision presented some obstacles. However, the content that was in the movie brought some speculation into whether or not the events of the movie were historically accurate. What is historically incorrect about the movie troy answers. The whole movie shows their battle struggles and the foreshadowing of fate in this adaptation of homers classic the iliad. But there is one thing that unites every historical movie ever made. Troy 2004 admittedly were not dealing so much here with ancient history. To understand the battle of kadesh it is important to know how the egyptian army and their chariots operated.

Here are 20 embarrassing movie costume mistakes that. That said, the film does indeed clash with the iliad and epic cycle and other such ancient greek. Inaccuracies in the film troy would be inaccuracies from a mythical, not historical perspective. At the start of the next shot, as the camera begins to pan down, on the far right, just beside a persons who is dressed in blue head is a metal bullhorn ie. The true story behind the netflix movie the king time. Historical movie try their best to be as accurate as possible.